At HHS, Brett Giroir Has Been Leading The Charge To Defund Lifesaving Research for HIV and Other Diseases that Utilizes Fetal Tissue, For Which No Alternatives Exist
In November 2018, OASH Secretary Brett Giroir Sent A Letter For Rep. Mark Meadows, Stating That HHS “Seeks To End The Use Of Fetal Tissue In Taxpayer-Funded Research If It Can Find ‘Adequate Alternatives.’” “Brett Giroir, the HHS assistant secretary of health, sent a letter to GOP Rep. Mark Meadows (N.C.) — the anti-abortion leader of the Freedom Caucus — describing the agency’s plan to move forward on alternatives to fetal tissue. The National Institutes of Health currently funds more than $100 million in research that draws on fetal tissue. In the letter, Giroir — one of the top officials involved in the agency’s ongoing review of fetal tissue research — says that HHS is ‘fully committed to prioritizing, expanding, and accelerating efforts to develop and implement the use of these alternatives.’ He also portrays HHS as ‘pro-life and pro-science’ under the Trump administration and says the agency did too little to find alternatives to fetal tissue under previous administrations. Parts of the letter were shared with POLITICO by a source.” [Politico, 11/16/18]
- Fetal Tissue Research Has Made “Major Contributions” For “Vaccines” And Continues To Be “Necessary For Medical Advances” For The Zika Virus And Other Diseases. “Fetal tissue research has made major contributions to the understanding of biology and the development of new medical technologies, including vaccines that have saved millions of lives. Cells from human fetal tissue were used in the development of several therapeutics in current use, as well as the ongoing production of critical vaccines (Wadman, 2017).... Below, we outline examples of how the use of fetal tissue has led to therapies that have saved lives as well as ways in which fetal tissue research continues to be necessary for medical advances. 1. Parkinson disease 2. Huntington disease 3. Blindness 4. Pregnancy 5. Zika Virus 6. HIV 7. Vaccines 8. Diabetes.” [International Society for Stem Cell Research, 2/17]
- Scientist Say Fetal Tissue Is Unique And Has No Alternatives. “There are no alternatives that can, today, serve all the same purposes as the controversial technology. ‘The consensus is that there are certain things about fetal tissue that make [it] unique,’ said Paul Knoepfler, a professor at the University of California, Davis, School of Medicine. ‘Certain experiments can really only be done on actual fetal tissue.’” [STAT News, 12/17/18]
As the Assistant Secretary for Health, Giroir has Overseen Changes to Critical Programs at the Behest of Anti-Abortion Activists
OASH Director Brett Giroir Oversaw The Efforts To Change The HHS’ Fetal Tissue Practices, Including An Abrupt Cancellation Of A Longstanding Contract With A Fetal Tissue Provider. “The simmering fight spilled into public view on Monday night, as HHS abruptly terminated one longstanding contract with a fetal tissue provider while opening an audit of all federally funded research and practices related to fetal tissue, which is mostly obtained from abortions. The health department, which cited ‘the serious regulatory, moral, and ethical considerations involved’ in using fetal tissue, also pledged to seek alternatives to fetal tissue for research purposes. … However, four individuals say that internal efforts to change the agency’s fetal tissue practices are being led by Assistant Secretary for Health Brett Giroir, whose office has overseen a number of changes sought by anti-abortion activists, including controversial changes to the Title X family planning program. Steven Valentine, who serves as Giroir’s chief of staff, also has been a voice representing the interests of anti-abortion advocates.” [Politico, 9/28/18]
-
Giroir Told Congressional Republicans That HHS Would Likely Cancel The Critical Fetal Tissue Contracts Because It Is A “Pro-Life” Agency. “Brett Giroir, the HHS assistant secretary of health, sent a letter to GOP Rep. Mark Meadows (N.C.) — the anti-abortion leader of the Freedom Caucus — describing the agency's plan to move forward on alternatives to fetal tissue….In the letter, Giroir — one of the top officials involved in the agency's ongoing review of fetal tissue research — says that HHS is “fully committed to prioritizing, expanding, and accelerating efforts to develop and implement the use of these alternatives.” He also portrays HHS as "pro-life and pro-science" under the Trump administration and says the agency did too little to find alternatives to fetal tissue under previous administrations. Parts of the letter were shared with POLITICO by a source.” [Politico, 11/16/18]